by Innoscout
Menu

Free template

Pitch competition scorecard

Six weighted criteria for a startup pitch jury, each with what a 1 and a 5 mean. Print the page as a score sheet, or start a free Innovote event with the same rubric.

The rubric

Pitch competition scorecard: 6 criteria, each scored 1 to 5
CriterionWeight1 means5 meansScore (1 to 5)
Problem15%No clear problem, or one that only the founders have.A clear, urgent problem for a defined customer, backed by evidence.
Solution and product15%Unclear what the product does or why it beats what customers use today.A clear product with a convincing edge over today's alternatives.
Market15%No idea who buys or how many buyers there are.A defined, reachable market with a credible size estimate.
Business model and traction20%No plan for revenue and no sign of demand.A clear revenue model and real proof: paying customers, pilots or strong growth.
Team20%Key skills are missing and there is no plan to fill them.The skills and track record to build and sell this.
Pitch and Q&A15%Hard to follow, and questions were left unanswered.Clear and on time, with convincing answers to the jury's questions.

Print this page for a paper score sheet: the menus and buttons drop away and a score column appears, one sheet per startup.

Why these criteria

Investor and founder juries judge a startup on whether there is a business, not only on the five minutes on stage. So the scorecard gives the most weight to the business model with its proof and to the team, and keeps the pitch itself at 15%.

Six criteria on a scale of 1 to 5 is about what a juror can score in the minute before the next startup plugs in a laptop. If your competition is for ideas rather than companies, give Traction less weight or replace it with “Validation”.

The audience award is not on this sheet. Run it as its own event in Innovote with one choice per voter, so the jury score and the people’s choice stay two separate awards.

How the total is calculated

Each startup’s score on a criterion is the average of all judges who scored it. The total multiplies each criterion’s average by its weight and divides by the sum of the weights (100), so it stays on the same 1 to 5 scale as the criteria.

Example: a startup scored 4, 4, 3, 2, 5, 4 gets (4 × 15 + 4 × 15 + 3 × 15 + 2 × 20 + 5 × 20 + 4 × 15) / 100 = 3.65.

This is how Innovote ranks a weighted scorecard. Judges see the weight next to each criterion, for example “Problem (15%)”. Startups with the same total, to two decimals, share a place.

Running the judging

  • Send the scorecard to the finalists before the event. Founders pitch better to criteria they know.
  • Brief the jury with the “1 means” and “5 means” columns. In Innovote the same two sentences show under each criterion on the juror’s phone.
  • Let each juror score alone. Jurors do not see each other’s scores: the results are for you and your co-organizers, and the voting page shows a ranking only if you switch that on.
  • Decide before the event how a tie is broken, for example by the Team score. Two startups with the same total share the place.

Entering it in Innovote

With one click: Start an event with this template. You name the event, and it starts with these 6 criteria, their weights and their descriptions, a scale from 1 to 5 without a 0, and judges who sign in with a username and PIN. Without an account you sign up first (free), and the template comes along.

By hand, in an existing event:

  1. In the event settings, under Sign-in, choose Username and PIN. Your screens then call the people who vote judges.
  2. Under Voting and rubric, choose Detailed scorecard and set the number of criteria to 6.
  3. For each criterion enter the title, 5 as Max points, the weight, and the “1 means” and “5 means” sentences as the description.
  4. Under Judge options, switch on Disable the “0” vote option, so the scale starts at 1.

Then add the startups (or switch on the application form under Entry fields and let them apply through its link), add the judges with their PINs or import them from a spreadsheet, print one card per judge, and put the voting link or its QR code on the screen.

What the rubric does not do

Innovote does not normalize strict and lenient judges: a judge who never gives more than a 3 pulls every startup they score down by the same amount, so let every judge score every startup when you can. It also does not assign judges to tables, and it does not blend a jury score with an audience vote.

Score your final with this rubric, free.